Condo ‘privacy’ ordinance unconstitutional, asserts lawsuit
Loop North News

CONDOMINIUM LIFESTYLE

6-Apr-18 – With less than two weeks before the new law takes effect, a lawsuit will challenge the constitutionality of an ordinance aimed at protecting the privacy of condominium unit owners.

Shorge Sato has filed a lawsuit in Cook County Circuit Court, asking a judge to void the ordinance, passed on March 28, that makes names, addresses, email addresses, telephone numbers, and weighted vote of each owner exempt from records a condo association must make available to an owner within ten business days of a written request.

Sato is a lawyer, unit owner, and secretary on his building’s condo board. He says the ordinance restricts owners from learning who is voting in condo board elections and what the actual results are, beyond what the condo board shares with owners.

He says the ordinance would prevent owners from knowing if they are being misled about a board election. Incumbent directors, he says, could “freely discard ballots, manufacture proxies, stuff ballot boxes, manipulate election results, and declare victors and losers without any meaningful ability to contest or challenge.”

Without knowing weighted votes of each owner, indicating relative influence on board elections, owners, says the lawsuit, would be unable to determine if elections are honest. The ordinance would then make it difficult for owners to organize opposition to their condo board.

Shorge Sato “In the name of ‘privacy,’ the [ordinance] would restrict the ability of condominium owners to hear any dissenting voices to the ‘party line’ of the condo board,” says Sato (left) in his lawsuit, filed on March 30.

Condominiums ‘creatures of state law’

Sato argues there is a conflict between a city ordinance that reverses state law and condominiums that cannot exist apart from state law.

“Condominiums are creatures of state law,” says the lawsuit. “The City of Chicago has no right to tamper with the very definition of what a condominium is, and how it is to be governed, especially on issues of fundamental importance such as the rights of condo board outsiders to disseminate information, to associate with fellow unit owners, to campaign for election and/or to vote in free and equal elections.”

He says the ordinance puts him, as a condo board secretary, in a legal bind because if a unit owner requests a unit owner list, election ballots, or proxies, “I have conflicting legal obligations and duties under state law – disclose – and Chicago ordinance – do not disclose.”

The ordinance, says the lawsuit, infringes on the constitutional right of unit owners to due process of law – specifically, that the city cannot “enact an ordinance that disenfranchises condo unit owners and denies them the right to campaign and vote in free and equal elections.”

By Steven Dahlman | Loop North News | sdahlman@loopnorth.com

Published 6-Apr-18 5:21 AM

Loop North News

FREE WEEKLY EMAIL UPDATE

What’s news in the Loop and Near North neighborhoods of downtown Chicago.

Signup for our weekly email. No ads and no charge. Just enter your email address here...

Number of subscribers:
See this week’s update

More stories


Today
Opening reception for Spirit of the Waves by Nelly Agassi. Through a body of work that includes a large-scale textile installation, intricate embroideries, works on paper, sculptures, and a performance, Agassi conjures historical and imagined narratives from the architectural details of Madlener House. Built in 190102 for Albert and Elsa Madlener, the house was renovated in the 1960s and transformed into Graham Foundation’s headquarters. The culmination of Agassi’s Graham Foundation Fellowship, this exhibition (May 23-August 3) explores erasure, preservation, identity, and architecture’s capacity to change. 6:00-8:00 p.m., Graham Foundation, 4 West Burton Place. Please RSVP. Map. More info.

Today
Opening reception for Somewhere Within, a joint sculpture exhibition by Blake Ward and his longtime partner Boky Hackel-Ward. Blake and Boky will be flying to Chicago from Monaco to attend. Although Blake’s name is well known throughout the art world, Boky Hackel was in the shadows as Blake’s partner in creation. After Blake’s publicist, backed by his representatives in Canada, discouraged him from telling anyone about his collaboration with Boky, he fired the publicist and gave Boky credit for her creative contributions. 5:30-8:00 p.m., Hilton Asmus Contemporary, 716 North Wells Street. Map. More info.
More events

Biggest Gainers & Losers

JBT CORPORATION
103.76 4.65

NORTHERN TRUST CORP.
90.16 3.20

AON PLC
178.30 2.66

LITTELFUSE INC.
167.29 2.41

Downtown Chicago Stocks