Realtors say Trump tax plan would hurt homeownership nationwide
Loop North News

The Home Front

8-May-17 – Housing advocates nationwide are turning their noses up at President Donald Trump’s proposed tax plan which would double the standard deduction and, in effect, invalidate the tax benefits of owning a home.

“Real estate now accounts for more than 19 percent of America’s gross domestic product, or more than $3 trillion in investment,” said William Brown, president of National Association of Realtors (NAR).

Photo by Nancy Rothstein “For roughly 75 million homeowners across the country, their home is more than just a number,” said Brown (left). “A home represents their ambitions, their nest egg, and the place where memories are made with family and friends. Targeted tax incentives are in place to help people get there.”

The mortgage interest deduction and the state and local tax deduction make homeownership more affordable, according to NAR.

“By doubling the standard deduction and repealing the state and local real estate tax deduction, the plan would effectively nullify the current tax benefits of owning a home for the vast majority of tax filers,” Brown said.

In addition, tax deferred real estate swaps – known as 1031 like-kind exchanges – help investors keep inventory on the market and money flowing to local communities, Brown noted. The 1031 tax deferred exchange also would be eliminated under the proposed Trump tax plan.

Housing analysts say that every time a home is bought or sold, the transaction creates a ripple effect through the economy. New furniture, appliances, and furnaces are purchased and hundreds of millions of dollars are spent on home remodeling and landscaping projects.

However, NAR said real estate tax incentives are at risk in the plan recently released by President Trump. The outcome of the changes, should they be enacted, could be devastating to homeownership, according to Brown.

“Current homeowners could very well see their home’s value plummet and their equity evaporate if tax reform nullifies or eliminates the tax incentives they depend on, while prospective homeowners will see that dream pushed further out of reach,” Brown said.

Doubling deduction could lower home values

National Association of Home Builders Chairman Granger MacDonald shared similar sentiments.

National Association of Home Builders (Left) Granger MacDonald (right in photo) and Vice President Mike Pence at The White House on February 28. (Image obtained from National Association of Home Builders.)

The changes could have an inverse impact, as well, on lower-income households, according to Diane Yentel, president and CEO of National Low Income Housing Coalition.

“By raising the standard deduction, President Trump’s tax plan also would lead to fewer households claiming the mortgage interest deduction [MID], a $70 billion tax write-off that primarily benefits higher-income households,” said Yentel (right). “Without additional reforms to provide a greater tax benefit to low and moderate-income homeowners – and to reinvest the savings into providing affordable rental homes to those with the greatest needs, Trump’s proposal would amplify MID’s regressive effect. Only the wealthiest Americans would benefit.” Diane Yentel

In addition, William Brown pointed to the majority share of federal income taxes paid by homeowners, cautioning that they could shoulder even more responsibility if the changes take effect.

“As it stands, homeowners already pay between 80 percent and 90 percent of the U.S. federal income tax,” said Brown.

Without tax incentives for homeownership, those numbers could rise even further, NAR forecasts.

“Common sense says that owning a home isn’t the same as renting one, and America’s tax code shouldn’t treat those activities the same either,” said Brown. “Major reforms are needed to lower tax rates and simplify the tax code but shouldn’t come at the expense of current and prospective homeowners.”

While the president’s tax proposal is well-intentioned, says Brown, “it’s a non-starter for homeowners and real estate professionals who see the benefits of housing and real estate investment at work every day.”

Regardless of the Trump tax plan’s impact on housing, a survey by NAR reported that nearly eight of ten Americans still believe that buying a house makes good financial sense. Here’s why…

• Owning a home is one of the best ways to build long-term wealth. Historically, a homeowner’s net worth has ranged from 31 to 46 times that of a renter, reports the Federal Reserve Survey of Consumer Finances. Homeownership today still represents a family’s primary means of financial advancement.

• Homeowners are free to renovate, redecorate, and modify their homes as they wish. If you want to paint the walls or make a simple landscaping change, there isn’t a landlord to stop you.

• For many, homeownership is a lifestyle choice – a place to raise a family, build memories, and be part of a larger community.

By Don DeBat | Loop North News | ddebat@loopnorth.com

Published 8-May-17 12:23 AM

Loop North News

FREE WEEKLY EMAIL UPDATE

See what’s news in the Loop
and Near North neighborhoods of downtown Chicago.

Signup for our weekly email. No ads and no charge. Just enter your email address here...

Number of subscribers:
See this week’s update


Today
Shoreline Sightseeing and Paulina Market present their sixth annual Beer, Brats and Boats Oktoberfest celebration and cruise. The evening will feature a classic German dinner provided by the staff of Chicago’s own Paulina Market and a selection of Oktoberfest brews, including a free drink with souvenir beer stein. The popular Paloma Band will be dressed in their traditional Oktoberfest finest and ready to involve everyone on board in an evening of enthusiastic German-themed singing and dancing. All on a starlit, two-hour cruise on Chicago’s waterways. Cash bar available. 7 p.m., Polk Bros Park at Navy Pier. Tickets: $59. Must be 21. Map. More info.

Through Sunday
19th annual World Music Festival. Diverse international musicians will celebrate the rich cultural diversity of Chicago. Performances at 23 venues. Cost: Free. Map. More info.

Through Sunday
The summer blockbuster exhibition Takashi Murakami: The Octopus Eats Its Own Leg at Museum of Contemporary Art. Known for his collaborations with pop icon Kanye West and fashion house Louis Vuitton, and for vibrant anime-inspired characters, Japanese artist Takashi Murakami has blurred the boundaries throughout his career between high and low culture, ancient and modern, East and West. MCA presents a major retrospective of his paintings, featuring 50 works that span three decades of his career, from the artist’s earliest mature works, many of which are being shown in North America for the first time, to his recent, monumentally scaled paintings. Museum of Contemporary Art, 220 East Chicago Avenue. Map. More info.

More events

S&P 500
2,500.60 7.64

NASDAQ COMPOSITE
6,422.69 33.35

LOOP/NORTH
44.55 0.05

Biggest Gainers & Losers

LITTELFUSE INC.
188.23 2.04

NORTHERN TRUST CORP.
90.84 1.16

CENTURY ALUMINUM CO.
19.39 0.99

Downtown Chicago Stocks